JPMorgan Assails U.K. Tax, Sparks Canary Wharf Doubt
JPMorgan Chase & Co. Chief Executive Officer Jamie Dimon, whose bank had promised to build a European headquarters in London, told U.K. Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling a 50 percent tax on bonuses would unfairly penalize the U.S. lender, a person close to the firm said.
Dimon reminded Darling that JPMorgan never took a U.K. bailout and said plans to build a European headquarters at Canary Wharf show the New York-based company’s commitment to London, the person said. JPMorgan, the second-largest U.S. lender by assets, may scrap its Canary Wharf project because of the bonus tax, the Financial Times reported, citing an unidentified bank executive.
Financial firms may face higher costs after Darling said on Dec. 9 he’d impose a 50 percent tax on discretionary bonuses greater than 25,000 pounds ($40,000). European and U.S. regulators imposed pay curbs after the world’s financial firms ran up $1.7 trillion in losses and writedowns during the global crisis.
“Jamie is quite a controlled character, so this is an example of the fury that has been created,” said Stuart Fraser, the head of policy for the City of London, the financial district’s lobby. “There is a real sense of indignation and anger about this tax.”
The tax may apply to compensation for about 20,000 people with the cost imposed on employers. During the call, Dimon, 53, mentioned that JPMorgan has paid U.K. taxes and reminded Darling of plans to spend about $2.4 billion on the Canary Wharf project, according to the person, who declined to be identified because the discussions were private.
U.K. Defends Tax
The conversation with Darling was reported yesterday by the London Telegraph. JPMorgan spokesman David Wells declined to comment. A U.K. Treasury spokesman yesterday defended the tax as fair because it would apply to all banks and said he couldn’t confirm the telephone conversation with Dimon.
“The government cannot allow itself to be blackmailed,” Liberal Democrat Vince Cable said today in an e-mailed statement.
Financial firms are threatening to leave the U.K. because they say increased taxes and regulation make London less attractive. Tullett Prebon Plc, the inter-dealer broker, said it will help employees relocate.
BlueCrest Capital Management Ltd., a London-based hedge- fund firm that oversees about $15.4 billion, plans to open a Geneva office, a person familiar with the situation said last month. As many as 50 of BlueCrest’s 300 employees in London may move, the person said.
Deutsche Bank, Nomura
Deutsche Bank AG CEO Josef Ackermann said on Dec. 12 that Germany has a “comparative advantage” over other financial hubs because it doesn’t plan to tax bonuses. The Frankfurt-based bank said it plans to spread the costs of the U.K. bonus tax to its employees worldwide.
Nomura Holdings Inc., the Tokyo-based bank that bought the U.K. operations of the collapsed Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., has no plans to reconsider its new City of London headquarters.
Nomura, which in August signed a 20-year lease for a 525,000-square-foot (48,774-square-meter) building overlooking the River Thames, will move into new offices in July, spokesman Patrick Meyer said in London today.
European Alternatives
The bonus levy forced Dimon to consider, “Do we want to be in a more tax-friendly, corporate-friendly environment?” said Jeff Harte, an analyst in Chicago for New York-based Sandler O’Neill & Partners LP. “There are opportunities all over Europe. There are a lot of cities that could handle operation hubs.”
JPMorgan agreed to pay about $349 million in November 2008 for land in London’s Canary Wharf financial district to build a 1.9 million-square-foot (176,500-square-meter) tower.
Under the agreement with Canary Wharf’s owners, who will build the offices, JPMorgan can scale back the size of the project. The planned headquarters will house JPMorgan employees from seven other buildings after the bank scrapped plans to build an office in London’s main financial district.
If construction is delayed or canceled, JPMorgan will have to pay a 76 million-pound fee to developer Canary Wharf Group Plc, according to a November 2008 statement when the deal was announced. The bank will be responsible for paying for completed work including design, planning and infrastructure, the statement said.
Banks’ ‘Sticks’
Shifting business centers elsewhere is “one of the sticks they’ll use to try and fight this legislation, but in the end how realistic is it?” said Joe Sorrentino, managing director at executive compensation consultant Steven Hall & Partners specializing in financial services. “This is a people business. How do you get your talent, if they’re U.K-based, to move to other countries?”
The U.K. Treasury is working with banks to identify employees who are excluded from the tax, and Darling said Dec. 16 he will resist calls to change the policy. Banks can’t avoid the levy by arguing that some activities aren’t defined as banking, he said.
Shares of Songbird Estates Plc, which controlled more than half the buildings in the Canary Wharf estate, were little changed at 157 pence at 3:04 p.m. in London trading. A spokesman for Songbird declined to comment. JPMorgan’s stock fell 4 cents to $41.68 at 12:43 p.m. in New York Stock Exchange composite trading.
“It comes as no surprise that the recent, knee-jerk and ill-thought-out tax grab by government to punish bankers is causing some of our most important institutions to consider their options,” said Mayor of London Boris Johnson. “This should act as a strong wake-up call to our leaders that their policies could seriously threaten our competitiveness.”